By Justin Berka | Published: January
24, 2008 - 12:07PM CT
When the iPhone was first released
last year, we saw Apple hit with a
number of patent infringement
lawsuits over the device. Apple has
been accused of copying multitouch
technology as well as the Visual
Voicemail feature, but things were
fairly quiet on the legal front
during the holiday season. The heat
is on once again, though, as a
company called Minerva Industries
has filed a lawsuit against Apple
and a company called AtlanticRT
alleging that the iPhone infringes
on one of Minerva's patents.
The case involves a patent just
awarded to Minerva this week. The
patent covers a "mobile
entertainment and communication
device," which Minerva feels is very
similar to the iPhone. The company
even let Apple know about the patent
filing in advance, but Apple took
its sweet time and only submitted
prior art a week before the patent
issuance. The USPTO took a look at
the prior art and granted the patent
anyway, prompting Minerva to accuse
Apple and AtlanticRT of
infringement.
Minerva wants Apple to stop using
the technology, but also wants the
usual boatload of damages, although
the boat won't be as big this time
since Apple has sold few iPhones
(compared to, say iPods). It's hard
to tell which track Apple will take
with this one. The recent USPTO
decision gives Minerva legal
ammunition, which might prompt Apple
to settle.