top
 
Nokia claims $1 billion Qualcomm paymentsgo
go


IDC releases year-end Worldwide Mobile Phone Tracker reportgo
go


Apple hit with yet another iPhone patent lawsuitgogo

Apple faces new lawsuit over iPhone conceptgo
go


Mobile entertainment to be driven by music, games and mobile TVgo
go


Injunction prohibits Qualcomm's infringement on Broadcom patentsgogo

Ericsson technology enables new safety device launched by NTT DoCoMogo
go


Suit Targets Biggest Players In Cell Phone Industry
go


'Pay-Buy Mobile' initiative announced by GSMA
go
Minerva Industries, Inc. Files Patent Infringement Lawsuit Against Apple, Inc . and Atlantic RT, Inc.go

more

The USPTO officially issued and published a new patent number #7,321,783go

more

Patent infringement suit filed by Minerva Industries, Inc.

more

 






Apple hit with yet another iPhone patent lawsuit

By Justin Berka | Published: January 24, 2008 - 12:07PM CT

When the iPhone was first released last year, we saw Apple hit with a number of patent infringement lawsuits over the device. Apple has been accused of copying multitouch technology as well as the Visual Voicemail feature, but things were fairly quiet on the legal front during the holiday season. The heat is on once again, though, as a company called Minerva Industries has filed a lawsuit against Apple and a company called AtlanticRT alleging that the iPhone infringes on one of Minerva's patents.

The case involves a patent just awarded to Minerva this week. The patent covers a "mobile entertainment and communication device," which Minerva feels is very similar to the iPhone. The company even let Apple know about the patent filing in advance, but Apple took its sweet time and only submitted prior art a week before the patent issuance. The USPTO took a look at the prior art and granted the patent anyway, prompting Minerva to accuse Apple and AtlanticRT of infringement.

Minerva wants Apple to stop using the technology, but also wants the usual boatload of damages, although the boat won't be as big this time since Apple has sold few iPhones (compared to, say iPods). It's hard to tell which track Apple will take with this one. The recent USPTO decision gives Minerva legal ammunition, which might prompt Apple to settle.